IMPROVING TEAM-SPORT PHYSICAL PERFORMANCE
LATEST HYPOXIC TRAINING PROPOSALS
– Written by Olivier Girard, Australia, Franck Brocherie, France, Raphaël Faiss and Grégoire Millet, Switzerland
Performing ‘all-out’ efforts in hypoxia (Repeated Sprint training in Hypoxia or RSH) may provide additional activation of anaerobic and neuromuscular pathways beyond that observed in normoxia.
Combining ‘traditional’ altitude methods (Live High-Train Low) and ‘innovative’ methods (Repeated Sprints training in Hypoxia), the so-called Live High Train Low and High or LHTLH, would boost both aerobic fitness and repeated-sprint ability in team sports.
Historically, altitude training for endurance athletes emerged in 1960s and was limited to the “Live High-Train High” (LHTH) method for those looking to increase their oxygen (O2) transport. This ‘classical’ method was complemented in 1990s by the “Live High-Train Low” (LHTL) method, where athletes benefitted from the higher intensity of training at lower elevations whilst simultaneously residing at altitude. The development of new research directions are usually derived from problems encountered in the field by practitioners.
UPDATED PANORAMA OF HYPOXIC METHODS
Recently, innovative “Live Low-Train High” (LLTH) methods have emerged as “Resistance Training in Hypoxia” or “Repeated-Sprint training in Hypoxia” (RSH) with the belief that up-regulated non-haematological peripheral adaptations may further improve high-intensity intermittent performance compared to normoxic controls1. “Resistance Training in Hypoxia” for instance, was proposed with or without vascular occlusion with the purpose of promoting hypertrophy and power production, yet with unclear benefits in the available literature2. A combination of hypoxic methods also represent an attractive solution. For example, “Live High-Train Low and High” (LHTLH) is a method whereby athletes “live high and train low except for few intense workouts at altitude”3. By combining LHTL and RSH, for instance, larger repeated-sprint ability (RSA) gains have been reported in team-sport players4. Similarly, the usefulness of the combination of LHTH and high-intensity training near sea-level (“Live High-Train High and Low”; LHTHL) was demonstrated in swimmers5. The scope of hypoxic training methods is now wider than in the past as it distinguishes RSH from traditional “Intermittent Hypoxic Training” (IHT) methods (Table 1) and the use of altitude training is no longer restricted to endurance athletes.
ALTITUDE TRAINING AND TEAM SPORTS
Team-sport players are required to repeatedly produce skilful actions at maximal or near-maximal intensity (e.g., accelerations, changes in pace and direction, sprints, jumps and kicks), interspersed with brief recovery intervals (consisting of rest or low- to moderate-intensity activity), over an extended period of time (1–2 h). Imperative performance characteristics of team-sport players are excellent RSA and large distance covered during the Yo-Yo intermittent recovery (Yo-Yo IR) test, both being associated with in-match physical performance6. High-intensity training under hypoxia likely improves buffering capacity, lactate exchange and removal, tissue O2 extraction, glycolytic enzyme activity, citrate synthase activity and myoglobin content. Despite a lack of strong scientific evidence, a growing number of team-sport athletes are using altitude training in the belief that it can promote greater physiological adaptations useful to improve in-game physical performance. Because of the limited time allowed in a competitive season to employ hypoxic interventions, it is therefore not surprising that LLTH methods, causing minimal disruption to technical and tactical training, encounter a large popularity in the team-sport community. As little as four “in season” RSH sessions, using either a cycle8or a double-poling9exercise mode, were beneficial to enhance repeated power production in World-level Rugby Union players during the short-term preparation to a major competition.
BEYOND INTERMITTENT HYPOXIC TRAINING: REPEATED SPRINTS IN HYPOXIA
The development of hypoxic facilities (O2-filtration chambers/tents or breathing hypoxic mixtures with a mask) within the last two decades has prompted the implementation of LLTH interventions. A thorough analysis of 20 studies including IHT leads to strikingly poor benefits for sea-level performance improvement, with only four studies bringing additional benefits in performance-related variables compared with similar training in normoxia10. To overcome some of the inherent limitations of IHT (e.g., lower training stimulus due to hypoxia), a new hypoxic training method was developed in Lausanne against the observation of an up-regulation of several genes mRNA only when exercise was performed at high-intensity and high altitude (and not at lower intensity)11. This model differs from IHT since the intensity of the training stimulus is maximal and therefore would allow one to maintain high fast twitch muscle fibre recruitment, so that positive results can be expected when adding hypoxia to training. RSH training is based on the repetition of short (<30 s) ‘all-out’ sprints with incomplete recoveries (<60 s) in hypoxia10,12. A lower rate of O2 delivery to the muscles increases the stress on glycolytic flux, which may stimulate the up-regulation of this energy pathway. Compared with repeated-sprint training in normoxia (RSN), RSH could induce beneficial adaptations at the muscular level, along with improved blood perfusion, which may lead to greater improvements in RSA10.
REPEATED-SPRINT TRAINING IN HYPOXIA AND PERFORMANCE IMPROVEMENTS
In our pioneer study, 40 trained male cyclists completing four weeks of RSH or RSN (against a control group with no specific repeated-sprint training) were tested before and after training for the determination of endurance performance, anaerobic capacity and RSA13. Whereas performance during a 3 min “all-out” time trial was not improved, RSN and RSH improved the average power output during 10 s sprints and a 30-s Wingate test post-intervention. A major finding of this study was that RSH delays fatigue during a repeated-sprint test to exhaustion (10-s sprints, 20-s recovery period until peak power output declined by 30%). Hence, the number of sprints completed increased by ~40% (from 9 to 13) in the RSH group, whilst the RSN group showed no such improvement (9 sprints before and after the intervention). A 2017 meta-analysis featuring nine controlled studies (over 200 individuals) indicated that RSH induces greater improvement for mean repeated-sprint performance during sea-level repeated sprinting than RSN12. In the altitude training area, RSH is of interest with 25 studies published by seven research groups in the past 5 years, with only two studies demonstrating no beneficial effects14. Practically, RSH benefits have been demonstrated for a large range of team- (rugby, football, LaCrosse, Australian Football, field hockey), endurance (cycling, track and field, cross-country ski), racket (tennis) or combat (Jiu-Jitsu) sports.
In soccer, Gatterer et al15showed that sport specific shuttle-run sprint training is feasible in hypoxic chambers of limited size (4.75 x 2.25 m) and is associated with a better running speed maintenance during a RSA test (lower fatigue slope) when compared to normoxia training. In highly-trained youth football players (Aspire Academy), the addition of 10 repeated-sprint training sessions performed in hypoxia vs normoxia to their regular football practice over a five-week in-season period was more efficient at enhancing repeated-agility ability (including direction changes), whereas it had no additional effect on improvements in lower-limb explosive power, maximal sprinting, RSA performance and maximal aerobic speed16. Interestingly, an additional benefit on in-game physical performance-related variables of RSH compared to RSN is present in all currently available studies.
In a group of elite rugby players, Galvin et al17found that four weeks of maximal RSH training induced a ~19% greater improvement in Yo-Yo IR1 performance compared with matched controls completing the same training under normoxic condition. Players also tended to cover more distance with a smaller speed decrement during the RSA test after hypoxic training, while 5-m sprint performance and RSA total time improved similarly in both training groups. RSH where hypoxia is induced by voluntary hypoventilation at low lung volume (named VHL) may also improve repeated-sprint performance more largely than with an unrestricted breathing pattern, as demonstrated by ~60% more sprints on average during an ‘open loop’ test carried out until a predefined exhaustion criteria in highly-trained rugby players18.
Overall, larger improvements in team-sport athletes’ ability to repeatedly perform predominantly aerobic high-intensity work (Yo-Yo IR and RSA tests) after hypoxic repeated-sprint training together with the lack of greater performance improvement during isolated maximal ‘all-out’ efforts of short duration (<30 s) would indicate that muscular oxidative activity rather than non-oxidative metabolism might be influenced by such training. The larger efficiency of RSH could relate to an increased muscular perfusion, an enhancement of growth hormone response, an ameliorated cerebral deoxygenation, a changed pH regulation and enhancement of the glycolytic capacity (PFK activity) and/or an increased expression of genes relating to O2 transport10,12,14.
The exercise-to-rest ratio likely plays an important role in the putative benefits after RSH because it modifies the energetic contribution of glycolysis and the fast twitches recruitment/activation during high-intensity exercise. Various activities and differing positions or playing styles within the same team sport creates a diversity of physiological challenges7. In light of each team-sport athlete needs, specific training focus (more aerobic vs. anaerobic type of adaptations) would imply that the effects of RSH may not be uniform across all players (e.g., larger anticipated benefits for midfielders or attackers compared to central defenders in football). Nonetheless, it is anticipated that players engaged in team sports (e.g., Australian league football) displaying shorter exercise-to-rest ratios and/or requiring prolonged time spent at high relative exercise intensity are more likely to benefit from such training.
At top level, coaches and athletes would be more likely to endorse the efficiency of a given intervention if results have direct relevance to their programmes and can be applied in a sport-specific setting (Figure 1). New technologies such as the mobile inflatable hypoxic marquees19now offer advancements of hypoxic training practical applications, notably with the opportunity to train (i.e., repeated sprinting over ~25 m, small-sided games, resistance training in hypoxia) under field-based hypoxic conditions. Training inside these marquees using a RSH paradigm has recently been successfully implemented with elite field-hockey players during in-season training camp in Doha (Figure 2).
Completing significant amounts of underpinning research is a prerequisite prior any attempts to implement strategies that have the potential to directly impact day-to-day activities in the ‘real world’. As a result, the time lag identified for the translation of research into “routine practice” usually exceeds 5-10 years. Only five years after the first published results, however, innovative RSH and LHTLH have already gained considerable popularity in the team-sport community14. Many training centres at terrestrial altitude or specialized centres with normobaric altitude dormitories (altitude residence for improved blood carrying capacity) also equipped with a climatic chamber (i.e., RSH for improved muscle factors and/or heat training for improved thermoregulation) now have the facilities for optimal preparation of team-sport players. Aspetar is fortunate to have World-class facilities for training with environmental stress. Through strategic partnerships, Aspetar attracts prestigious national teams for optimal competition preparation. In recent years, French Rugby Federation squads have successfully tested new RSH (female Sevens national team) or LHTLH with heat training (male U20) training regimens for the purpose of refining best practice (Figure 3).
LIVE HIGH-TRAIN LOW AND HIGH
Although aerobic metabolism dominates the energy delivery during most team sports, decisive actions (e.g., sprints and jumps) are covered by means of anaerobic metabolism. As a result, the demands of team sports lend themselves towards a potential edge from hypoxia-derived aerobic and anaerobic adaptive mechanisms. LHTLH has been recently validated as an attractive combination (LHTL + RSH) to elicit concurrent aerobic and anaerobic performance-related physical fitness traits in team sports (Figure 2). With a low hypoxic dose (≥200 h), LHTLH conducted for two weeks during the in-season period of elite field hockey players was efficient to elicit immediate up-regulated haemoglobin mass (+4%) and an increase in Yo-Yo IR2 performance (+20%), yet with similar gains compared to sea-level training (LHTL + RSN)4. However, the superiority of the LHTLH over the LHTL + RSN method was demonstrated on the RSA test (8 x 20 m, 20 s rest) with twice larger acute performance gains, those being well maintained at least for three weeks post-LHTLH intervention only. Analysis of muscle biopsy samples indicated an overexpression of transcription factors involved in O2-signaling and O2-carrying capacity and mitochondrial metabolism enzymes for LHTLH20.
Altitude training has traditionally targeted endurance-based athletes, but more recently, the use of LLTH approaches and in particular the emergence of the RSH paradigm used in isolation or combined with ‘traditional’ methods (the so-called LHTLH), is gaining considerable attention in team sports. It is thought that this practice may maximize high-intensity exercise performance through an improved ability to resist fatigue and eventually greater outcome of crucial situations (preserved technical and tactical behaviour and wise cognitive choice) in the most intense periods of a game or towards the end of a match. By adding hypoxic stress to repeated-sprint training, a large number of studies available to date demonstrate larger, short-term (2-6 weeks) benefits associated with RSH on several indices of repeated-sprint performance enhancement, compared to similar training at sea level. Considering the complexity of match running performance and numerous factors influencing it (pacing strategies, mental fatigue, contextual and tactical factors), determining whether individual post-RSH physical performance enhancements would also positively impact a team’s game result remains a considerable challenge.
Olivier Girard, Ph.D.
Murdoch Applied Sport Science (MASS) laboratory, Murdoch University
Franck Brocherie, Ph.D.
Laboratory Sport, Expertise and Performance (EA 7370)
Research Department, French Institute of Sport (INSEP)
Raphael Faiss, Ph.D.
REDs, Research and Expertise in antiDoping sciences, Institute of Sports Sciences (ISSUL), University of Lausanne
Grégoire P Millet, Ph.D.
Institute of Sports Sciences (ISSUL), University of Lausanne
Girard O, Brocherie F, Millet GP. Effects of altitude/hypoxia on single- and multiple-sprint performance: A comprehensive review. Sports Med 2017; 47:1931-49.
Scott BR, Slattery KM, Dascombe BJ. Intermittent hypoxic resistance training: does it provide additional benefit? Front Physiol 2014; 5:397.
3. Millet GP, Roels B, Schmitt L, Woorons X, Richalet JP. Combining hypoxic methods for peak performance. Sports Med 2010;40:1-25.
Brocherie F, Millet GP, Hauser A, Steiner T, Rysman J, Wehrlin JP, Girard O. "Live High-Train Low and High" Hypoxic Training Improves Team-Sport Performance. Med Sci Sports Exerc 2015; 47:2140-9.
Rodriguez FA, Iglesias X, Feriche B, Calderón-Soto C, Chaverri D, Wachsmuth NB. Altitude training in elite swimmers for sea level performance (Altitude project). Med Sci Sports Exerc 2015; 47:1965-78.
Brocherie F, Millet GP, Hauser A, Steiner T, Wehrlin JP, Rysman J, Girard O. Association of hematological variables with team-sport specific fitness performance. PLoS ONE 2015;10(12): e0144446.
Bishop DJ, Girard O. Determinants of team-sport performance: implications for altitude training by team-sport athletes. Br J Sports Med 2013; 47:17-21.
Beard A, Ashby J, Chambers R, Brocherie F, Millet GP. Repeated-sprint training in hypoxia in international rugby union players. Int J Sports Physiol Perform 2019; in press.
Beard A, Ashby J, Kilgallon M, Brocherie F, Millet GP. Upper-body repeated-sprint training in hypoxia in international rugby union players. Eur J Sport Sci 2019; in press.
Faiss R, Girard O, Millet GP. Advancing hypoxic training in team sports: from intermittent hypoxic training to repeated sprint training in hypoxia. Br J Sports Med 2013;47:i45-i50.
Vogt M, Puntschart A, Geiser J, Zuleger C, Billeter R, Hoppeler H. Molecular adaptations in human skeletal muscle to endurance training under simulated hypoxic conditions. J Appl Physiol 2001; 91:173-82.
Brocherie F, Girard O, Faiss R, Millet GP. Effects of repeated-sprint training in hypoxia on sea-level performance: a meta-analysis. Sports Med 2017; 47:1651-60.
Faiss R, Leger B, Vesin JM, Fournier P-E, Eggel Y, Dériaz O, et al. Significant molecular and systemic adaptations after repeated sprint training in hypoxia. PLoS ONE 2013; 8:e56522.
Millet GP, Girard O, Beard A, Brocherie F. Repeated sprint training in hypoxia – an innovative method. Dtsch Z Sportmed 2019; 70:in press.
Gatterer H, Philippe M, Menz V, Mosbach F, Faulhaber M, Burtscher M. Shuttle-run sprint training in hypoxia for youth elite soccer players: A pilot study. J Sports Sci Med 2014; 13:731-5.
Brocherie F, Girard O, Faiss R, Millet GP. High-intensity intermittent training in hypoxia: a double-blinded, placebo-controlled field study in youth football players. J Strength Cond Res 2015; 29: 226-37.
Galvin HM, Cooke K, Sumners DP, Mileva KN, Bowtell JL. Repeated sprint training in normobaric hypoxia. Br J Sports Med 2013; 47:i74-i79.
Fornasier-Santos C, Millet GP, Woorons X. Repeated-sprint training in hypoxia induced by voluntary hypoventilation improves running repeated-sprint ability in rugby players. Eur J Sport Sci 2018; 18:504-12.
Girard O, Brocherie F, Millet GP. On the use of mobile inflatable hypoxic marquees for sport-specific altitude training in team sports. Br J Sports Med 2013; 47:i121-i123.
Brocherie F, Millet GP, D'Hulst G, Van Thienen R, Deldicque L, Girard O. Repeated maximal-intensity hypoxic exercise superimposed to hypoxic residence boosts skeletal muscle transcriptional responses in elite team-sport athletes. Acta Physiol (Oxf) 2018; 222.